| Dr Olmsted, | Jan. 9th, 1865. |
Your letter has just come to hand dated Decr 9th. I shall write to you soon. In the meantime you may be interested in the Brooklyn affair although nothing may come of it. Stranahan induced me to go over the other day & examine the site with him and a Mr Taylor who has recd a financial appt under the Commrs. The latter seems an undemonstrative man who probably takes the position as a moderately easy way of securing a competent annual remuneration. He is Stranahan’s next door neighbour and is a lawyer, of between 50 & 60, I should think.
I found that the Prest, for S is Prest, was inclined to increase the boundaries on the south and east sides to some considerable extent. On examination of the ground in this direction & in connection with an impression gained when on the ground last summer, I did not hesitate to recommend him, if he went to the Legislature at all, to make some such modification as the one indicated on the sketch. He had not supposed the cheap flat land valuable for Park purposes but I explained to him that by securing it the Commrs could make a skating pond deserving the name and in this particular easily surpass their Competitors the C.P. Moreover as the land on this side, with the exception of the lots marked expensive lots, could be bought for less than half the price of that on the other side and as the plan of having a hundred foot avenue running through the Park was an objectionable feature and the ground on the Washington
[295
]Avenue side was generally unsuited for Park purposes, being in an awkward shape, I suggested that this be, not perhaps immediately abandoned, but entirely thrown out of the Park scheme except so far as a control of the lots bordering on the avenue was concerned & this perhaps only for a short distance near the principal entrance as the Ave was unsuited for handsome residences. By this means the cost of the desirable addition would be very little—as the Washington Avenue section is valuable & increasing in value—and the Reservoir with its steep formal banks and artificial constructions and splendid view could be connected with the Park by a flying bridge—and all cumbrous & expensive structures in connection with crossing over or under Flatbush Avenue avoided. The lie of the land, the diagonal direction of the streets, & the near propinquity of Greenwood Cemetery, which occupies a large tract, and the general relation of Brooklyn to the work seems to suggest that transverse Roads may be omitted without detriment to public convenience, perhaps. However, one may be called for.
Stranahan absorbed the idea rapidly enough and if Saturday had been fine I was to have gone over the ground with him again as he is anxious to get the subject before the Legislature this season. He had previously asked me what I would make a plan for, & I told him that I should probably ask $10,000. This somewhat alarmed him, but he asked me con amore to come over & see the ground, and I have sketched the results. If it should end in any decided modifications I suppose that my chance will be no worse. I really however approach the subject with a feeling akin to dislike, fearing to be annoyed as we were in the CP affair. We are all pretty well. Love to y’ wife.
C. Vaux
Calvert Vaux’s Sketch of Proposed Boundary Chances for Prospect Park, Brooklyn,
January 9, 1865
Sketch in upper left corner shows position of Prospect Park in relation to Greenwood Cemetery, the built-up section of Brooklyn, and Wallabout Bay, Williamsburgh, and Manhattan (“New York Island”). The main sketch shows the original boundaries proposed for Prospect Park, on both sides of Flatbush Avenue, indicated by continuous lines. Vaux’s proposed extension of the park, all on the right side of Flatbush Avenue, is indicated by dashes. His new section includes, starting at the top, the outline of the “Proposed Pond of say 40 acres”; the “Hilly Region” just below it; the Quaker Cemetery and nearby Railway Station; and the “Rather Expensive Lots” along the lower boundary street (Ninth Avenue, now Prospect Park West). Along Ninth Avenue facing the park, Vaux indicated the position of “Lots recommended to be secured to make a row of sites under Commrscontrol.” The “Principal natural Entrance from Brooklyn” (to be constructed as Grand Army Plaza) is indicated at the junction of Flatbush Avenue and Ninth Avenue.